Spectacle of Participation

The permanent permanent campaign

Artwork by Tony Tulathimutte.

The world’s richest country with the highest rate of child poverty among OECD nations, the United States also enjoys the distinction of having the lowest voter turnout combined with the longest political campaign seasons. Before candidates announce their campaigns, they must raise money and hire staff so that their campaigns are seen as viable; afterward, they must continue to raise money with an eye to each campaign-finance filing deadline, when they must demonstrate to the media (and future donors) that they have sustained momentum among voters and “cash on hand.” If elected, they must continue to raise funds while in office, in preparation for the next election. This cycle afflicts the House of Representatives most of all, since their offices are up for reelection every two years.

But the presidency — with its grotesque fusion of republicanism, monarchism, and military junta — commands the most attention. It is the object of nearly continuous national fantasy, albeit for only a minority of the potential electorate; media speculation on future electoral prospects commences the moment in November when the loser concedes. Presidents in office have come to conduct their governmental activities in the form of a “permanent campaign,” in the words of Sidney Blumenthal, author of a prescient study of political consultants published in 1982. “It remakes government into an instrument designed to sustain an elected official’s public popularity,” he wrote. “It is the engineering of consent with a vengeance.” Blumenthal later became an adviser to President Bill Clinton, until recently the most avid permanent campaigner in the history of the presidency.

Those seeking to challenge permanently campaigning incumbents must also be in permanent campaign mode. The timing of announcements has changed dramatically over the past half century. Thomas Dewey, the eventual Republican nominee for President in 1948, announced his campaign in January of that year. By the time George McGovern announced in January 1971 — some eighteen months before the Democratic nominating convention — campaigns had lengthened. Both parties would come to adopt more open nominating procedures. This meant that the parties now had considerably less power to define themselves (even if, as recent political science maintains, they eventually reconstituted the power of party bosses in an “invisible” primary of agreements and deals that took place before the commencement of the contest). The vagaries of the primary “season” — really, encompassing several actual seasons — lengthened. Another feature of the new primary process was that candidates and their personalities became decisive. Telegenic, consultant-driven campaigns became the norm. Campaign strategists focused on polling, messaging, and television — Michael Deaver, Lee Atwater, Karl Rove, David Axelrod — became almost as well known as the candidates themselves. Their importance to the candidate, and the importance of the campaign-style of governing to the presidency, was obvious from the fact that most strategists were installed in the administration when the candidates became President.

More from Issue 35

Issue 35 Savior Complex
On the Mueller Report, Vol. 1
Issue 35 Savior Complex
Issue 35 Savior Complex

I usually worked with a camera in the room. That didn’t mean that the content of my work was performance rather than service.

Issue 35 Savior Complex
Parasite Air
Issue 35 Savior Complex
Predatory Inclusion
Issue 35 Savior Complex

I wasn’t selling furnace and duct cleaning. I was selling my voice, the fantasy it could embody. I was selling a myth of…

Issue 35 Savior Complex
The Feminist
Issue 35 Savior Complex

Is it weird to think that one day I could photoshop you out of all this? he said. That I could obscure your face with a brush,…

Issue 35 Savior Complex

In my dreams, I think I can conquer death.

Issue 35 Savior Complex
Dreams Are Lost Memories
Issue 35 Savior Complex
On Design Thinking
Issue 35 Savior Complex

More by this Author

Issue 19 Real Estate

They looked like some army of the damned, out to fight zombies—but in fact they were facing down their own police.

Issue 6 Mainstream

Canons in daily life just demarcate the books you can count on other people feeling comfortable about in conversation.

Issue 12 Conversion Experience

We would chat while they thought we were working; they would grow old and die; we would inherit the earth and chat forever.

Issue 41 Snake Oil

What will the long-term political consequences of the vaccine mandates be?

Issue 9 Bad Money

Web 2.0 has been revelatory; the torrent of writing from ordinary folks has been especially transfixing.

January 13, 2009

You just find you’re standing athwart History, and History’s like, “I want to review the Susan Sontag diaries.”