Trolling and Taboo

A coup d’état in the collective unconscious

My father loathes telemarketers. It’s not such a big deal anymore now that my parents don’t have a landline, but when I was growing up I used to race to answer the phone, with its pink cord and handset, to avoid the inevitable: my dad yelling at the telemarketer to never call us again. He was angry whenever I let slip that we were indeed the Renner household. He put us on the Do Not Call list. Even so, a few rings seeped through. So he came up with a way to prank them.

One day when I came home from school—I was 9, 10, 11—he showed me three sheets of notepaper filled front and back with a handwritten monologue. It was to be read in any order, starting anywhere on any page, whenever a telemarketer or wrong number called. The pages sat next to the phone, ready at all times, and went something like this:

But did you talk to Mary yet? Because she talked to Kevin and apparently he called the whole thing off. No, no, not that Kevin. Kevin with curly hair. So I say to Mary, “Look, Mary, we’ve got a problem! You can’t just go around treating people this way! When you say you’re going to do something, you’ve gotta do it. Don’t flake out on me. I don’t care what Kevin says.” Oh oh oh, you want to speak to Mary? No, Mary’s not here. I don’t know where she lives now, she just up and left one day, took all her suitcases and poof. How inconsiderate, with the kids and everything. But back in the day when she was dating Kevin we used to see her all the time. But where was I . . .

And so on—fictional gossip, contentless drama, automatic writing. Pretending he had called them. Telemarketers, it seemed, were the perfect target: they were not allowed to hang up, so you could launch into a monologue they were helpless to escape. It was hilarious. I was too chicken to read it myself, but when my father read it I was thrilled. We were testing the limits of customer service. Slowly alienating the marketer was, I thought, better than outright hostility or abuse.

More from Issue 30

Issue 30 Motherland
In the Maze
Issue 30 Motherland
When a Person Goes Missing
Issue 30 Motherland

For the first time, we are living in a truly post-cold-war political environment in the US

Issue 30 Motherland
The Keeper
Issue 30 Motherland
Estación Origen MADRID
Issue 30 Motherland

Nothing good comes of forcing desire to conform to political principle. You could sooner give a cat a bath.

Issue 30 Motherland

You spy the owner of the telecom monopoly, holding an iPhone above his head, trying to find a signal.

Issue 30 Motherland
Morbid Capitalism
Issue 30 Motherland
Issue 30 Motherland

The happy ending in It is that a group of kids beats a clown to death. Today that qualifies as wishful thinking.

Issue 30 Motherland

Turning the pages of the manual—A in a circle, B in a circle, C in a circle, D in a circle, E in a circle, F in a circle, G in…

Issue 30 Motherland

I hate travel (ethnography), yet here I am (philosophy).

Issue 30 Motherland

Capitalism is eating its young. It’s only feeding us avocados to fatten us up first.

Issue 30 Motherland

The best way to ensure the future of literary criticism is to address the problem of economic inequality.

More by this Author

July 8, 2019
Tanks for Nothing
Issue 42 Vanishing Act

Everyone on TV was just going through the motions. It felt like watching the death spiral of civilization.

December 30, 2019
Confessions of a Mask
November 11, 2016

The lines of communication were clearly jammed, if virtually no poll saw this coming.

February 2, 2018
Issue 37 Transmission

The pandemic had lifted up the rotting log of philosophy, and the philosophers were wriggling about in the sunlight.